This one was awesome and really helped build upon Alex Rodriguez's reputation as a pansy. Allegedly here's what happened: A-Rod gets plunked in the elbow by Bronson Arroyo. A-Rod complains to Bronson that it hurt instead of taking his free pass like a man. Our hero, Jason Varitek, tells A-Rod "c'mon Alex...you know we don't hit guys batting .250 on purpose." Fight ensues. Who knows if it's what really went down, but we like to think it is. Red Sox 11, Yankees 10.