September 17, 2007

Some Disagreements

As you can tell if you read this blog often, the two of us agree on a lot of stuff--hence the frequent use of the term "we." However, there are things about which we disagree. We will post about these things approximately whenever we feel like it.

What is your early-season opinion of West Virginia?

Abram: I honestly don't know what to think. Obviously, Slaton has a lot of speed and ability. Freshman Noel Devine looked superb against Maryland and he will likely be a special back in the next couple of years as well. And Pat White is a smart quarterback who is fun to watch. I guess my problem is, it's tough to really know how good the Mountaineers are because they literally don't play a single team that I believe is a legit Top Ten squad. Rutgers, Louisville, and South Florida, you say? Please. USF may be the best team among those three. UL has no defense at all and Rutgers is just as unproven as WVU. The fact remains that this team was unimpressive against Marshall and I just don't think they could stay on the field with the likes of LSU, Oklahoma, USC, Florida--and possibly even Texas--in a big game. Therein lies my main issue with West Virginia: I would hate to see them undefeated and playing for the national championship over any of those other teams should they have one loss. A no-loss Mountaineers team would be, in my opinion, the best argument yet for a playoff system. They deserve a shot, but ought to have to prove they belong before just being handed a spot in the championship game.

Jeff: Why are we trying to create controversy after week three? Usually these things work themselves out. Plus, wasn't a no-loss Auburn a good case for a playoff? I'm not sure I'd take West Virginia to go undefeated this season, but they are the team that I would HATE to see in a bowl game. Between Pat White, Steve Slaton and now Noel Devine, this team has more offensive speed than any team in the country. Steve Slaton is my early favorite for Heisman, and they present match up problems for just about every team in the country. If the Mountaineers are turning it over or the offense is out of rhythm, they may drop a game or two this season. If they go undefeated they'll have a good shot at winning a championship.

How would Appalachian State fare in D-I?

Abram: I honestly believe that Notre Dame is the worst of the 3 teams Michigan has played thus far. In 10 meetings, Appy State beats ND 6 or 7 times. Yes, they are I-AA. Yes, they have fewer scholarship players. But these guys are fast! Did you see any of the highlights of the Michigan game? Michigan's secondary couldn't catch ASU skill players with 1- and 2-yard head starts. That likely speaks also to how slow Michigan is, BUT: Notre Dame is equally slow, if not more so. I think Appy State would finish no worse than the middle of the pack in most BCS conferences, and would win several non-BCS I-A conferences. This is a better team than, say, Arkansas State.

Jeff: No, Appy State is still Appy State. They may be better than two-thirds of D-I teams, but according to the power rankings list that I checked, that makes them equal with...Central Florida. Hmmm...I may need to go back to the tape and take a look at them again. I'd say New Orleans Bowl contender in I-A

How do you feel about the Transformers Movie?

Abram: The Transformers Movie is a movie about a cube, from outer space, that can turn any device into a Transformer. One of the main characters is a truck named Optimus Prime. This is a movie with such an insanely ridiculous premise that it simply doesn't matter whether the military component of the plot has any semblance of accuracy.

Jeff: We are just going to have to agree to...agree. What a crappy movie. Not only did the Transformers plot line make zero sense, the American response makes no sense. The V-22 Osprey blows up in the beginning of the movie, which is just about the only realistic thing in the whole damn thing. The acting was awful, and the Transformers were nothing like I'd imagined in my dreams. I saw a bit less believable version of Transformers when I thought about this film, and that is not was I got.


JBRATER said...

Long response!

1 West Virginia will probably have 1-2 crappy losses in the "if 'big 'means good, than not very 'big,' but probably 'bigger' than the big ten (if "ten" means eleven") which is ... yeah... east this year, but if they do make it through unscathed, I think one of the top ranked teams would smack them around. (Especially LSU... Geaux.)That said, the idea of a team like... oh say... Michigan... trying to stop slaton and white is enough to give me a resigned chuckle.

2) I'm pretty sure appy state is a good team... probably would compete for a crappy bowl in "bowl subdivision. oooooh, bowl subdivision." ... but yeah. it still sucked to lose to them. But after Oregon, it's hard to know how to evaluate that game. Is it still the biggest upset ever? Idunno. Does it still prove appy can play? Idunno. Oh, and Notre Dame is terrible. so terrible. so very terrible. Oh, so very terrible. Oh, so very very terrible. Winning 38-0 is nice, since Michigan has never blown out Notre Dame... at least not in the last 4 years... or at least not in the last 4 years not counting 2004 and 2006... but I still don't think Michigan will beat penn state. Then again, Michigan does have mike hart. man love!

3) Transformers sucked, but the cartoon movie from 1986 is amazing. YOU GOT THE TOUCH!!!


Adam said...

Best argument against a playoff:

9/3 Louisiana-Lafayette W 60-3 1-0 (0-0)

9/10 at No. 4 Ohio State W
25-22 2-0 (0-0)

9/17 Rice W 51-10 3-0 (0-0)

10/1 at Missouri W 51-20 4-0 (1-0)

10/8 Oklahoma W 45-12 5-0 (2-0)

10/15 No. 24 Colorado W 42-17 6-0 (3-0)

10/22 No. 10 Texas Tech W 52-17 7-0 (4-0)

10/29 at Oklahoma State W 47-28 8-0 (5-0)

11/5 at Baylor W 62-0 9-0 (6-0)

11/12 Kansas W 66-14 10-0 (7-0)

11/25 at Texas A&M W 40-29
11-0 (8-0)

12/3 at Colorado W 70-3 12-0 (8-0)

1/4 vs No. 2 USC W 41-38 13-0 (8-0)